Recent Documents

All documents uploaded in the last 60 days

7/30/2015
Ex Ante Review
Final
PG&E
HVAC Technology
Optimization, Temperature Reset Control
The customer completed a retro-commissioning project in an 11-story multi-tenant office building. The project implemented three measures: (1) revised hot deck OA reset scheduling, (2) optimum start/stop AHU controls, and (3) OA damper repairs to allow airside economizing.
12/16/2013
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology
Optimization, Temperature Reset Control
The customer completed a retro-commissioning project in an 11-story multi-tenant office building. The project implemented three measures: (1) revised hot deck OA reset scheduling, (2) optimum start/stop AHU controls, and (3) OA damper repairs to allow airside economizing.
3/10/2021
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology
Response to the ED comments and questions.
11/18/2013
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, Linear Fluorescent Fixture, HID Fixture
Replacing HID fixtures with LED and linear fluorescent fixtures.
1/15/2013
Ex Ante Review
Phase 2
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, Linear Fluorescent Fixture, HID Fixture
Replaced HID fixtures with LED and linear fluorescent fixtures.
11/19/2013
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology
Cooling Tower Fan Control
The RCx project at a school district involves the following measures at six buildings: EEM-3: Reduce operating hours of air conditioning (AC) units and heat pumps, EEM-4: Set cooling tower (CT) fans condenser water (CW) pumps speed to 0% when the chiller does not operate, and EEM-5: Increase lock out temperature of economizers in AC units and heat pumps. The project also implemented two other measures; EEM-1 - replace existing AC units with high efficiency units, and EEM-2 - replace existing heat pumps with high efficiency heat pumps. However, the IOU incentives, hence have not been considered as the project scope.
1/13/2014
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology
Optimization, Temperature Reset Control
39 RCx measures at six healthcare campuses. At boilers, measures include: optimization of boiler controls, steam pressure resets, hot water temperature resets, and lockout schedules. At air handling units, measures include: optimization of AHU scheduling, economizer controls, cold/hot deck temperature controls, and supply air temperature reset controls. At air conditioning units, measures include: optimization of operating schedules, supply air temperature resets, and static pressure resets. At terminal boxes, measures include: optimization of operating schedules and minimum flow adjustments.
1/24/2014
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology
Temperature Reset Control
Supply air temperature resets for four AHUs, airflow setback for one AHU, chilled water supply temperature reset, and heating hot water supply temperature reset
3/3/2014
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Controls, Lighting - Fixtures
Light Sensor, LED Fixture, Linear Fluorescent Fixture
The project involves interior lighting retrofit to replace T8 and T5 linear fluorescent fixtures with T8 linear fluorescent and LED fixtures. The project also involves the installation of dimming controls in select areas of the building.
10/17/2013
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Pump System
Pump - General Purpose Motor
Ag Pumping: Replace agricultural well pump and bowl.
2/25/2014
Ex Ante Review
Final
PG&E
Pump System
Pump - General Purpose Motor
Replace agricultural well pump and bowl.
10/31/2013
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology, Lighting - Controls
Optimization, Light Sensor
EEM-1: Implement optimum start sequence of AHU-1. EEM-2: Install occupancy sensors in core restrooms for lighting control.
11/26/2013
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
All Equipment
Current Limiting Protector (CLiPs): Installation of CLiPs to bypass the existing line reactors on the high voltage bus between incoming PG&E lines and the plant as well as the refinery's cogeneration unit to reduce power losses (I^2R losses) during normal operations.
12/16/2014
Ex Ante Review
Final
PG&E
Any
Optimization, All Equipment
New Construction Plastic Recycler: Installation of a new construction plastics extrusion line with a high efficiency extruder.
11/26/2013
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
Optimization, All Equipment
New Construction Plastic Recycler: Installation of a new construction plastics extrusion line with a high efficiency extruder.
12/20/2014
Ex Ante Review
Final
PG&E
Any
Heat Recovery
Install mechanical vapor re-compressor (MVR) to recover waste heat and increase production capacity.
8/11/2014
Ex Ante Review
Phase 2
PG&E
Any
Heat Recovery
Install mechanical vapor re-compressor (MVR) to recover waste heat and increase production capacity.
7/2/2014
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
Heat Recovery
Install mechanical vapor re-compressor (MVR) to recover waste heat and increase production capacity.
1/14/2014
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology
Centrifugal Water Chiller, Adjustable Speed Drive
The proposed measure involves replacement of one existing chiller (CH-6) with a high efficiency chiller at a telecommunication and data center facility in California CZ 03. The customer also proposes to replace another existing chiller (CH-5) with a high efficiency chiller under a separate incentive application (2K13215903).
1/3/2014
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
All Equipment
Ring valve upgrade: Replacing plate valves with ring valves.
11/27/2013
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology, Lighting - Controls, Lighting - Fixtures
Temperature Reset Control, LED Fixture, Adjustable Speed Drive
This retrofit project at two hospital complexes involved 29 Energy Efficiency Measures (EEMs).
12/26/2013
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
LED fixtures: The project will replace the exterior High Pressure Sodium (HPS) and Metal Halide (MH) fixtures with LED Fixtures.
11/9/2013
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Steam Circulation
Pipe Insulation, Steam Trap
Pipe Insulation & Stream Trap Replacement: EEM1 - Replace failed open steam traps, and EEM2 - Insulate remaining bare steam and hot water pipes.
11/20/2013
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology
Heat Recovery
The customer is retrofitting three existing 100% outside air handlers in a office building to allow recirculated airflow during periods of heating (the building will still use 100% OA during cooling periods).
12/5/2014
Ex Ante Review
Final
PG&E
HVAC Technology
Heat Recovery
Install outside air dampers and controls on three AHUs to allow heat recovery from return air.
11/28/2014
Ex Ante Review
Final
PG&E
HVAC Technology
HVAC Exhaust Fan - General Purpose Motor, HVAC Return Fan - General Purpose Motor
Install laboratory HVAC system controls to reduce supply and exhaust air volume during occupied and unoccupied periods.
12/14/2013
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology
HVAC Exhaust Fan - General Purpose Motor, HVAC Return Fan - General Purpose Motor
Install laboratory HVAC system controls to reduce supply and exhaust air volume during occupied and unoccupied periods.
1/10/2014
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Pump System
Pipe Insulation
Insulate bare surface hot water pipes, flanges, valves, pumps and strainer surfaces with 1-1.5 inch thick mineral fiber blanket and canvas jacket sleeving.
2/27/2014
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
All Equipment
Sawmill Upgrade: Replace hydraulic drives with electronic drives; upgrade the large log mill that will increase production by 15%, while simultaneously reducing the connected load by 690 HP.
2/27/2014
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
All Equipment
Sawmill Upgrade: Replace hydraulic drives with electronic drives; upgrade the large log mill that will increase production by 15%, while simultaneously reducing the connected load by 690 HP.
12/30/2013
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
All Equipment
Ring valve upgrade: Replacing plate valves with ring valves.
12/27/2013
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Food Service
All Equipment
Food Processing Evaporator System Modifications: Replace single effect evaporator system with a three effect evaporator system that includes MVR and TVR.
12/30/2013
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology
Reciprocating Water Chiller, Screw Water Chiller, Adjustable Speed Drive
Chiller Retrofit; Plant Controls: The customer is replacing a 72-ton, watercooled, dual compressor, Carrier glycol reciprocating chiller with a new 89-ton, water-cooled, Carrier glycol screw chiller. The customer is also retrofitting their primary and secondary glycol and condenser water pumps with variable speed drives and implementing a condenser water temperature reset control strategy.
3/18/2014
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
All Equipment
Hydrogen System Controls Upgrade: Reclaim vented process hydrogen as refinery boiler fuel.
4/15/2014
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
All Equipment
Hydrogen System Controls Upgrade: Reclaim vented process hydrogen as refinery boiler fuel.
2/4/2014
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
All Equipment
REEP-108 Data Requests: The implementer states that Hydrogen is currently being vented and it is standard practice to vent Hydrogen. From prior experience staff consultants feel that the venting claim is unsupportable. By law, refineries in California are not allowed to vent highly combustible gas such as Hydrogen in the air. Any excess Hydrogen produced is normally piped into the refinery gas, and excess volume, if any, may be burned under the emergency flare rules. That occurrence is extremely rare. Staff consultants, therefore, are unable to accept the implementer's claim that Hydrogen venting is standard practice. In our opinion, ISP is piping Hydrogen into the refinery pipeline or burning it to produce process heat. Since Hydrogen has some BTU value, it is inconceivable that a refinery that is buying natural gas from a utility would not use the purest form of Hydrogen produced by the methane reformer. Please submit evidence in the form of permit to demonstrate that millions of therms of Hydrogen is being allowed to be vented. Also submit a low-rigor ISP study to support the claim of venting Hydrogen, not reusing it as fuel is standard practice. This is a show-stopper review and the ISP study is triggered by a project application. Therefore, this project and all similar projects will remain on hold until the ISP claim is substantiated. Staff consultants expected PG&E's own show-stopper assessment to have accompanied this application.
7/22/2014
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Whole Building
Water Side Economizer
New data center pods in existing building.
9/5/2014
Ex Ante Review
Phase 2
PG&E
Whole Building
Water Side Economizer
New data center pods in existing building.
6/24/2014
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
All Equipment
Advanced Controls using Aspen Software: Controls are to be added to improve the operation of two hydrogen process trains.
4/29/2014
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
Optimization, All Equipment, Gas Furnace
Furnace #2 Upgrade: The scope of the project is to refurbish an existing glass furnace with energy reducing upgrades that allow capacity increases at lower gas input per unit of product delivered.
4/23/2014
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
All Equipment
UPS Replacement: Replacing two UPS units with three more efficient UPS units.
2/6/2015
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any, Whole Building
All Equipment
Whole Building New Construction: Whole building energy evaluation for office building.
3/10/2021
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
All Equipment
New Pipeline: New oil pipeline diameter increased from baseline 12" to 16."
8/26/2014
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
All Equipment
Static switch installation: This project adds new load switching technology to two existing 500 kW uninterruptible power supplies. The switches raise the systems operating efficiencies to approximately 99% from their assumed baseline efficiencies of ~93%.
6/12/2015
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any, HVAC Technology
Optimization, All Equipment
Install new automotive paint process: The project is a new paint booth system in an automotive manufacturing facility. The project includes the installation of the pretreatment dip tanks, electro-deposition undercoating tank, paint spray booths including the HVAC systems serving them.
1/26/2015
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Air Compressor
Optimization
Compressed air system modifications: Replace air compressor sequencing controller, repair air leaks, adjust system pressure set points, and replace timer drains with no loss drains.
1/28/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Anaerobic Digestor
All Equipment
Industrial Strategic Energy Management: 463772: Retrocommissioning - Monitoring Based Retrocommissioning
1/28/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
All Equipment
Industrial Strategic Energy Management: 463772: Retrocommissioning - Monitoring Based Retrocommissioning
9/9/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Pump System
Pump - General Purpose Motor
Agricultural Energy Advisor - Deemed Downstream - Advanced Pump Efficiency. Process retrofit/New-Pumps-Repair.
9/23/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Pump System
Pump - General Purpose Motor
Agricultural Energy Advisor - Deemed Downstream - Advanced Pump Efficiency: PROCESS RETROFIT/NEW-PUMPS-REPAIR
9/23/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Pump System
Pump - General Purpose Motor
Agricultural pump system overhaul - retrocommissioning: Overhaul of 100 HP Turbine Well Pump at Dairy Barn North Well pump.
9/18/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
Agricultural Calculated Incentives: Horticultural LED lighting
8/20/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
Heat Recovery, LED Fixture, HID Fixture
LIGHTING RETROFIT/NEW-INT LED HORTICULTURAL: Install 256 high efficiency air cooled LED horticultural lighting in an indoor facility expansion with a baseline of 50/50 CMH and LED fixtures.
10/17/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Food Service
All Equipment
PROCESS RETROFIT/NEW-FAN-VFD, PROCESS RETROFIT/NEW-FAN-EFFICIENT UNIT: Installation of (63) 72" New Free Stall High Efficiency Barn Fans as an New Load Project
11/19/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Pump System
Pump - General Purpose Motor
Agricultural Energy Advisor - Deemed Downstream - Advanced Pump: Process Retrofit/New Pumps Repair
11/19/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology
Adjustable Speed Drive
Add floating head pressure controls, an auto-purger unit to eliminate non-condensable air, and add VFD controls on the air handler units in the cold storage building at a large wine production facility. Measure 1 REFRIGERATION - EVAPORATOR - FAN CONTROLLER - To-Code/Std Measure 2 REFRIGERATION RETROFIT/NEW-SYSTEM-ADD/MODIFY EQUIPMENT Measure 3 REFRIGERATION - CONTROLS - FLOATING HEAD PRESSURE - To-Code/Std
11/19/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Pump System
Pump - General Purpose Motor
Agricultural Energy Advisor - Deemed Downstream - Advanced Pump: PROCESS RETROFIT/NEW-PUMPS-REPAIR
12/3/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Pump System
Pump - General Purpose Motor
Agricultural Energy Advisor - Deemed Downstream - Advanced Pump: Process Rtetrofit/New Pumps Repair.
3/10/2021
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Pump System
Pump - General Purpose Motor
Agricultural Energy Advisor - Deemed Downstream - Advanced Pump: Process Rtetrofit/New Pumps Repair.
12/3/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Pump System
Pump - General Purpose Motor
Agricultural Energy Advisor - Deemed Downstream - Advanced Pump: Process Rtetrofit/New Pumps Repair
2/11/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Refrigerated Storage
Adjustable Speed Drive
(7) Refrigeration measures for a salad greens processing plant. Measure 1 REFRIGERATION - CONDENSER - VFD - To-Code/Std Measure 2 REFRIGERATION - EVAPORATOR - FAN CONTROLLER - To-Code/Std Measure 3 REFRIGERATION - SYSTEM MODIFY - To-Code/Std Measure 4 REFRIGERATION RETROFIT/NEW-COMPRESSOR-INSTALL VFD Measure 5 REFRIGERATION RETROFIT/NEW-CONTROLS-FLOATING HEAD PRESSURE Measure 6 PROCESS COMPRESSED AIR - SYSTEM CONFIGURATION - To-Code/Std Measure 7 PROCESS RETROFIT/NEW-COMPRESSED AIR-MODIFY
1/21/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
LIGHTING RETROFIT/NEW-INT LED HORTICULTURAL: Replacing HPS DE with 100 horticultural LED fixtures at a cannabis
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
LIGHTING RETROFIT/NEW-INT LED HORTICULTURAL: Replacing HPS DE with 100 horticultural LED fixtures at a cannabis.
3/10/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
All Equipment
The replacement of existing fans with HE Fans and VFDs as a New Load
9/23/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 3
PG&E
HVAC Technology
Optimization
Chilled water plant optimization (RCx) at biotech facility
11/12/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology
Temperature Reset Control
RCx for (3) large office/production buildings in Milpitas.
11/19/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology
All Equipment
Replacement of existing air filter setup with higher efficiency air filters in a hospital and adding one new bank of air filters.
11/19/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology
All Equipment
Replacement of existing air filter setup with higher efficiency air filters in a hospital and adding one new bank of air filters.
11/19/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Whole Building
All Equipment
RETROFIT-EXISTING-COMMERCIAL WHOLE BLDG-ANALYTICS
11/25/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology
Temperature Reset Control
Retrocommissioning of large commercial office building to optimize.
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Heat Rejection Equipment
Window Film
Install V33 window film on 3 joined 7 story office buildings.
11/26/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Heat Rejection Equipment
Window Film
Install V33 window film on 3 joined 7 story office buildings.
11/23/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology
Air Economizer
Enable outside air economizing for data center.
3/17/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Whole Building
All Equipment
Savings by Design (SBD) - Savings by Design Whole Building. New Elementary school located includes 5 buildings.
5/11/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Whole Building
All Equipment
Savings by Design (SBD) - Savings by Design Whole Building. New Elementary school located includes 5 buildings.
2/11/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Whole Building
All Equipment
Savings by Design (SBD) - Savings by Design Whole Building: New Construction Middle school of 117,520 sf which includes 5 buildings.
4/7/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Whole Building
All Equipment
Savings by Design (SBD) - Savings by Design Whole Building: New Construction Middle school of 117,520 sf which includes 5 buildings.
3/10/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology
All Equipment
Retrocommissioning project at a 565,400 square foot Hospital and Office building.
6/10/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology
All Equipment
Retrocommissioning project at a 565,400 square foot Hospital and Office building.
3/10/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Whole Building
Area Whole-building Improvements
Savings by Design (SBD) - Savings by Design Whole Building: Add controls to a fan system at a produce packing facility.
11/12/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Motor Speed Control (Non-HVAC)
Adjustable Speed Drive
Add VFDs on four 50-250 HP pumps on various systems at a Silt and Clay Mine
9/18/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
Lighting Retrofit/New-Exterior-LED-Pole Mounted
10/8/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
Replace 110 exterior HID lighting fixtures (MH1000 Watt) with 110 DLC approved, Antec Lighting INC fixtures, qualified on 3.18.19; Product ID PC6E4NHL.
10/8/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Ballasts, Lighting - Fixtures, Lighting - Lamps
LED Fixture, Linear Fluorescent Fixture, HID Fixture
Replace (304) T12, T8, and T5 linear fluorescent lamps, (47) exterior High Pressure Sodium and Metal Halide lamps/ballasts, and (7) high bay fixtures with LEDs in a food processing plant.
9/30/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
Incandescant to LED Pole Fixtures
9/30/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
Incandescant to LED Pole Fixtures
10/8/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
MH to LED Highbay
10/18/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, Linear Fluorescent Fixture
Retrofit of 2 T12 8FT 4L to (8) 60cm LED Strips w/ Existing Diffuser at a 4000sqft.
10/19/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures, Lighting - Lamps
LED Fixture, Linear Fluorescent Fixture, HID Fixture
Retrofit of 4 400W MH to 150W LED Pole Mount Retrofit
11/12/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
Retrofit of 2 250W HID to 60W LED Pole Mount Retrofit
10/22/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
Replace (11) HID exterior flood fixtures with new LED fixtures.
11/27/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures, Lighting - Lamps
LED Fixture, Linear Fluorescent Fixture, HID Fixture
Replace MH or HPS with LED High Bay Fixture
12/17/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Whole Building
All Equipment
University of California/California State University - SBD Whole Building: New construction, 5-story mixed research lab
12/17/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Whole Building
All Equipment
University of California/California State University - SBD Whole Building: New construction, 5-story mixed research lab.
1/14/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Lamps + Ballasts
Linear Fluorescent Fixture, LED Lamp
T8s to LEDs
7/30/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Lamps + Ballasts
Linear Fluorescent Fixture, LED Lamp
T8s to LEDs
12/10/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
HID to LED Pole Mounted
2/11/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
Replaced/Retrofit (9) MH 150w 1L with (9) LED Area 25w 4000K Type 3 (70-120w HID).
1/7/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Lamps + Ballasts
Linear Fluorescent Fixture, LED Lamp
Replaced/Retrofit (183) T8 4' 32w 4L NBF - Existing 2nd Gen with (183) (4)KT-LED12T8-48G-835-E(1)KTLD-4LT8-UV-12C-VDIM at a Retail - Single-Story Large (RTL) facility
1/7/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
Replaced/Retrofit (168) Ceramic Metal Halide 70W PAR38 with (168) LED Fixture 2x4 Troffer 48W Lithonia at a Grocery (GRO) facility.
1/28/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Lamps + Ballasts
Linear Fluorescent Fixture, LED Lamp
Replaced/Retrofit (27) T8 4' 32w 4L NBF - Existing 3rd Gen with (27) LED.
1/21/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
Replaced/Retrofit (6) MH 1000w 1L with (6) LED Fixture Area Light
1/28/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures, Lighting - Lamps + Ballasts
LED Fixture, Linear Fluorescent Fixture, LED Lamp
Retrofit (26) 4L 4' T12 w LED troffer
3/3/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
Replaced/Retrofit (8) MH 400W 1L with (8) LED Fixture Flood 150W
2/4/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
Retrofit (8) 400W MV w LED flood.
2/25/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Lamps
Linear Fluorescent Fixture, LED Lamp
Replaced/Retrofit (68) T8-4'-32w-1st Gen-2lamp-El-RS-NLO with (68).
1/21/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Lamps
CFL Fixture, Linear Fluorescent Fixture, LED Lamp
Replaced/Retrofit (23) CFL Bi-Pin (2) 40W with (23) LED Troffer Kit 2x2
4/7/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Lamps
CFL Fixture, Linear Fluorescent Fixture, LED Lamp
Replaced/Retrofit (23) CFL Bi-Pin (2) 40W with (23) LED Troffer Kit 2x2
3/5/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Whole Building
All Equipment
California Community Colleges - Savings by Design Whole Building: New construction of three community college buildings with a gross floor area of 24,448 sf.
4/3/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
Replace MH or HPS with LED High Bay Fixture
2/11/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Lamps
Linear Fluorescent Fixture, LED Lamp
LED Mag Strips replacing high wattage T8's
2/11/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, CFL Fixture, HID Fixture
HID to LED and CFL to LED.
3/17/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures, Lighting - Lamps
LED Fixture, Linear Fluorescent Fixture, HID Fixture
Replaced/Retrofit (1) HPS 250w 1L with (1) LED Area 80w 5000K Type 5 (400w HID) NBAL NebuLite at a Assembly (ASM) facility
2/25/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures, Lighting - Lamps
LED Fixture, Linear Fluorescent Fixture, HID Fixture
T8 to LED and HID to LED.
11/7/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Food Service
Optimization, All Equipment
Install (52) 72-inch high efficiency fans in free stalls at a dairy.
1/21/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Food Service
Optimization, All Equipment
Install a total of (90) 72-inch high efficiency fans.
8/4/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Food Service
Optimization, All Equipment
Install a total of (90) 72-inch high efficiency fans.
11/5/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Heat Rejection Equipment
Pipe Insulation, Steam Trap
Install insulating jackets over the various steam pipes, valves, and steam traps.
6/10/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Heat Rejection Equipment
Pipe Insulation, Steam Trap
Install insulating jackets over the various steam pipes, valves, and steam traps.
11/21/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Lamps
Linear Fluorescent Fixture, LED Lamp
linear fluorescent to LED
11/22/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Lamps
Linear Fluorescent Fixture, LED Lamp
linear fluorescent to LED
11/22/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Lamps
Linear Fluorescent Fixture, LED Lamp
Retrofit 1,197 interior fluorescent T8 fixtures (4,644 lamps) with a General Electric LED lighting technology
11/22/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, Linear Fluorescent Fixture
Retrofit interior fluorescent T8 fixtures with LEDs.
12/18/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Lamps
LED Lamp, Linear Fluorescent Lamp
Replace 108 F32T8 with TLEDs in hotel space.
2/25/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures, Lighting - Lamps + Ballasts
LED Fixture, Linear Fluorescent Lamp with Ballast
Replace (58) 2-lamp T8 fixtures with 1-lamp LED fixtures in RtL - Retail
9/5/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Motor Speed Control (Non-HVAC)
Adjustable Speed Drive, Pump Control
VFD on water injection pump
10/4/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
Heat Recovery
Installation of insulation on a rotary dryer shell drum to reduce heat loss at an asphalt plant
10/4/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
Optimization
Replace 4 existing turbine aerators used for mixing with high efficiency directional boosting mixers at a municipal wastewater plant.
8/21/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Motor Speed Control (Non-HVAC)
Adjustable Speed Drive, Pump Control
Add three Variable Frequency Drives on the three 30HP wine transfer pumps that are currently operating by manual throttle control through slide valves.
10/1/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology
Optimization
Optimize the controls sequences for duct static pressure setpoint based on zone demand in an office tower.
10/1/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology
Optimization
Optimize the controls sequences for duct static pressure setpoint based on zone demand in an office tower.
11/5/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Pump System
Pump Control
Pump Sequencing for a municipal water district
11/12/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
All Equipment
Accelerated Replacement (AR) of a non-cycling, refrigerated dryer with a cycling, refrigerated dryer.
12/3/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Air Compressor
Optimization
Add iZ Systems Automation Platform to eight compressor system ((1) 300 HP, (2) 250 HP, (1) 200 HP, (2) 150 HP, (1) 100 HP and (1) 75 HP) located in four separate areas running on their individual pressure bands to control all compressors centrally based on rate of pressure change algorithms on central pressure signals.
12/18/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Motor Speed Control (Non-HVAC)
Optimization, Adjustable Speed Drive
Install (2) 200 HP variable frequency drive (VFD) oil free compressors, install (2) heated dryers, install 5,220 gallons of storage, and install no loss air drains to replace the existing (7) non VFD compressors and purge air dryers at a computer hardware
1/21/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
All Equipment
Add Floating Head Pressure (FHP) Control to existing winery
1/28/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology
Temperature Reset Control
Implement eight (8) RCx BRO measures at a telecom central office
1/31/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
All Equipment
Addition of ductwork, dampers and actuators to allow partial recirculation of exhaust air that will reduce temperature rise at the 1.8 MMBTU/hr burner for seven existing industrial laundry facility dryers.
2/18/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Air Compressor, Food Service
Optimization
Replace one 75 hp fixed speed oil-flooded rotary screw compressor (with load/unload control) with one new 50hp variable speed drive (VSD) rotary screw compressor, in a food processing facility.
3/24/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology
Optimization
Replace standard v-belts with synchronous drive belts on 22 exhaust fans, 14 AHU supply fans and six AHU return fans at a bio-technology facility.
4/6/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
Install 727, new Fluence VYPR 2p horticultural LED fixtures in an indoor controlled environment agriculture facility instead of HID fixtures.
6/1/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Motor Speed Control (Non-HVAC)
Adjustable Speed Drive
Measure 1: PROCESS RETROFIT/NEW-FAN-EFFICIENT UNIT Measure 2: PROCESS RETROFIT/NEW-FAN-VFD
7/14/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Motor Speed Control (Non-HVAC)
Adjustable Speed Drive
Measure 1: PROCESS RETROFIT/NEW-FAN-EFFICIENT UNIT Measure 2: PROCESS RETROFIT/NEW-FAN-VFD
6/11/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology
Adjustable Speed Drive
HVAC RETROFIT/NEW-CHILLERS-WATER COOLED-VFD CHILLER
6/23/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Pump System
All Equipment
PROCESS RETROFIT/NEW-PUMPS-APPLICATION ASSIST
6/18/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
Install a new load of 522 Philips horticultural LED fixtures in 3 houses of a greenhouse for vegetative growth of cannabis
7/13/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Pump System
All Equipment
Agricultural Energy Advisor - Deemed Downstream - Advanced Pump
11/19/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Evaporative Cooling Equipment
All Equipment
Early retirement of a Tomato Processor's single-effect evaporator with a new system that will use both mechanical vapor recompression (MVR) and multi-effect evaporator technologies to reduce overall energy usage while maintaining capacity to evaporate 40,000 pph of water from inlet tomato product.
2/28/2017
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Pump System
Optimization, Pump Control
Add controls to prioritize the operation of well pumps to minimize system energy intensity at a municipal water district.
7/15/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
All Equipment
The Installation of (93) 51" New Free Stall High Efficiency Barn Fans with direct drives in Dairy in Bakersfield, as a New Load project.
3/18/2021
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology
Temperature Reset Control
RCx targeting CHW plant, AHUs and select lab spaces (focusing on CRAH & IRC optimization) in a high tech lab.
6/8/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Whole Building
All Equipment
New construction Savings by Design project, consisting of four-story, 179,000 sqft office building.
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
All Equipment
NMEC Whole Building
8/11/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
All Equipment
NMEC Whole Building
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
All Equipment
NMEC Whole Building
8/3/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology, Whole Building
Optimization, Temperature Reset Control
Retrocommissioning project of 3-building campus which includes the following measures: Enable ESS mode on five main UPS's, enable overnight setbacks and implement Optimum Start routine, tune cooling control and commission DSP and SAT resets, and improve airflow and temperature control in data center.
5/12/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
All Equipment
MF-Home Upgrade-Total Products Rebate
5/12/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Whole Building
All Equipment
MF-Home Upgrade-Total Products Rebate
5/12/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Whole Building
All Equipment
Energy Upgrade California - Deemed - Multifamily Upgrade: MF-Home Upgrade-Total Products Rebate
5/11/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Whole Building
All Equipment
Energy Upgrade California - Deemed - Multifamily Upgrade: MF-Home Upgrade-Total Products Rebate
5/12/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Whole Building
All Equipment
Energy Upgrade California - Deemed - Multifamily Upgrade: MF-Home Upgrade-Total Products Rebate
5/12/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Whole Building
All Equipment
Energy Upgrade California - Deemed - Multifamily Upgrade: MF-Home Upgrade-Total Products Rebate
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Whole Building
All Equipment
Energy Upgrade California - Deemed - Multifamily Upgrade: MF-Home Upgrade-Total Products Rebate
6/30/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology
All Equipment
Residential New Construction - Residential New Construction - Deemed: INTEGRATED BUILDING-RES-SINGLE FAMILY - WHOLE HOUSE 15-20%
6/2/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology
All Equipment
Residential New Construction - Residential New Construction - Deemed: INTEGRATED BUILDING-RES-SINGLE FAMILY - WHOLE HOUSE 15-20%
6/2/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology
All Equipment
Residential New Construction - Residential New Construction - Deemed SF: INTEGRATED BUILDING-RES-SINGLE FAMILY - WHOLE HOUSE 15-20%
6/30/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
Residential New Construction - Residential New Construction - Deemed: Enrollment Incentives
6/30/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
Residential New Construction - Residential New Construction - Deemed: Enrollment Incentives
8/7/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology, Lighting - Fixtures, Whole Building
Dishwasher, Faucet Aerator, Showerhead
This is a 296 unit apartment community consisting of multiple buildings of different sizes and arrangements, with extensive outdoor areas. The installed retrofits include: LED common area and apartment lighting Low-flow faucet aerators and showerheads Smart thermostats Energy efficient dishwashers and refrigerators Attic insulation up to R-30
7/13/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology, Lighting - Fixtures, Whole Building
LED Fixture, Faucet Aerator, Showerhead
This is a 309 unit low-rise apartment complex. This site underwent the following upgrades: NEST smart thermostats Low-flow faucet areators, 1.0-gpm and 1.5-gpm Low-flow showerheads at 1.5-pgm High efficacy apartment lighting High efficacy common area lighting VSD recirc pumps for DHW system
7/13/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology, Lighting - Fixtures, Whole Building
LED Fixture, Faucet Aerator, Showerhead
This is a 309 unit low-rise apartment complex. This site underwent the following upgrades: NEST smart thermostats Low-flow faucet areators, 1.0-gpm and 1.5-gpm Low-flow showerheads at 1.5-pgm High efficacy apartment lighting High efficacy common area lighting VSD recirc pumps for DHW system
7/7/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
All Equipment
Residential New Construction - Residential New Construction - Deemed: Enrollment Incentives
3/16/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures, Lighting - Lamps
LED Fixture, Linear Fluorescent Fixture, HID Fixture
Replace exterior pole mounted HID and interior linear fluorescent with LEDs.
3/17/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
Retrofit (45) 1000W MH w LED retrofit kit
3/17/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures, Lighting - Lamps + Ballasts
LED Fixture, Linear Fluorescent Fixture, HID Fixture
Replace linear fluorescent interior lighting and exterior pole mounted and wall mounted lighting with LEDs.
3/10/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
Replaced/Retrofit (36) MH 250W 1L with (36) LED Retrofit Area Light 120W ESL Vision at a Office - Large (OFL) facility
3/10/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures, Lighting - Lamps + Ballasts
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
Replacing linear fluorescent highbay interior and exterior pole and wallpack lighting.
3/30/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology, Whole Building
All Equipment
SBD New Construction of 54,000 sqft college campus building that is currently designed to be 16.1% better than 2016 Title 24.
4/6/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
57 - LED 240W Floods replacing 1000W MH 35 - LED 40W Canopy replacing 250W MH 11 - LED 60W Wall Packs replacing 250W MH
5/18/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
57 - LED 240W Floods replacing 1000W MH 35 - LED 40W Canopy replacing 250W MH 11 - LED 60W Wall Packs replacing 250W MH
5/8/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
(10) LEDone LOD-MAAL-100W-50K-TPIII-SBA fixtures at 100W were installed, replacing the existing 400W HPS fixtures (3) Verlux ST45W27V50KA fixtures at 45W were installed, replacing the existing 250W HPS fixtures (7) James Lighting ZY-15W1200 BONS (5000K) fixtures at 30W were installed, replacing the existing 59W 4ft 32W 2-lamp fixtures (7) James Lighting ZY-15W1200 BONS (5000K) fixtures at 30W were installed, replacing the existing 118W 4ft 32W 4-lamp fixtures (11) James Lighting ZY-15W1200 BONS (5000K) fixtures at 30W were installed, replacing the existing 109W 8ft 59W 2-lamp fixtures (3) LEDone LOD-FL-50W50K-HL fixtures at 50W were installed, replacing the existing 250W HPS fixtures
5/1/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, CFL Fixture, HID Fixture
Replaced/Retrofit (149) CFL Bi-Pin (2) 26W with (149) LED Retrofit and exterior lighting with LEDs.
4/6/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Lamps
Linear Fluorescent Fixture, LED Lamp
Replaced/Retrofit (425) T8-4'-32w-1st Gen-3lamp-El-IS-VHLO with (425) LEDs.
4/24/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Lamps
Linear Fluorescent Fixture, LED Lamp
Replaced/Retrofit (425) T8-4'-32w-1st Gen-3lamp-El-IS-VHLO with (425) LEDs.
4/28/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Food Service, HVAC Technology
Adjustable Speed Drive
Add variable-speed demand ventilation controls to the kitchen exhaust at a large hotel.
4/27/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
Replace MH or HPS with LED Exterior Fixture
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
Replace MH or HPS with LED Exterior Fixture.
5/29/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
Measure 1: Replace twelve (12) HID Canopy fixtures with LED fixtures (Measure code CLB81). The retrofit includes installation of LED fixtures in the following existing exterior lighting fixture types: Replace (12) – 400 Watt High Pressure Sodium Canopy fixtures with (12) – 100 Watt LED fixtures Measure 2: Replace one (1) HID Flood fixtures with an LED fixture (Measure code CLB50). The retrofit includes installation of an LED fixture in the following existing exterior lighting fixture type: Replace (1) – 250 Watt High Pressure Sodium Flood fixture with (1) – 50 Watt LED fixture Measure 3: Replace five (5) HID Wall Pack fixtures with LED fixtures (Measure code CLB52). The retrofit includes installation of LED fixtures in the following existing exterior lighting fixture types: Replace (5) – 400 Watt Metal Halide Wall Pack fixtures with (5) – 80 Watt LED fixtures
5/20/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
Measure 1: Lighting Retrofit/New-Exterior-LED-Pole Mounted Measure 2: Lighting Retrofit/New-Exterior-LED-Wall Mounted
5/26/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology, Whole Building
All Equipment
SBD new construction of 345,000 sqft office building with high efficiency insulation, lightin and HVAC exceeding T24 by 14.4%.
7/7/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology, Whole Building
All Equipment
New construction of a two-story clinical consultation, research and admin office building, with total floor area of 164,099 sqft.
5/26/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
Replacing interior highbay lighting with LEDs.
5/28/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
Replaced interior highbay lighting with LEDs.
5/26/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
Replaced exterior pole and canopy lighting with LEDs.
6/22/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology, Whole Building
All Equipment
New construction, 5-story mixed research lab, with a gross conditioned square footage of 164,491 sqft aiming for 12.1% better than baseline.
6/22/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology, Whole Building
All Equipment
New construction, 4-story Computational Lab, with a gross conditioned square footage of 87,476 sqft aiming for 10.9% better than baseline.
6/30/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology, Whole Building
All Equipment
New construction, 3-story Academic Leadership and Enrollment Center, with a gross conditioned square footage of 74,804 sqft aiming for 35.8% better than baseline.
7/14/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology, Whole Building
All Equipment
New construction, 2-story Wellness Facility, with a gross conditioned square footage of 27,562 sqft aiming for 23.2% better than baseline.
6/30/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
Replacing exterior pole lighting with LEDs.
7/15/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
Replaced exterior pole lighting with LEDs.
7/17/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures, Lighting - Lamps + Ballasts
LED Fixture, Linear Fluorescent Fixture, HID Fixture
Replaced interior general area lighting and exterior pole and wall pack lighting with LEDs.
6/26/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures, Lighting - Lamps
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
Replace exterior pole lighting with LEDs.
6/26/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures, Lighting - Lamps + Ballasts
LED Fixture, Linear Fluorescent Fixture, HID Fixture
Replaced interior general lighting and exterior pole lighting with LEDs.
8/5/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Lamps
Linear Fluorescent Fixture, LED Lamp
BASIC LIN LED T8 REPLACEMENT LAMP NON-DIMM RETROFIT KITS
7/2/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Lamps
Linear Fluorescent Fixture, LED Lamp
BASIC LIN LED T8 REPLACEMENT LAMP NON-DIMM RETROFIT KITS
7/14/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
LIGHTING RETROFIT/NEW-INT LED HIGHBAY
3/10/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Food Service
All Equipment
Install a total of (76) 72-inch and (60) 50-inch high efficiency fans in free stalls at a Dairy.
3/10/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Air Distribution
Optimization, Thermostat
To optimize the air flow and cooling of the telecommunications switching equipment by directing the cold air at the inlet of equipment only.
3/24/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Cleaning Equipment
Dishwasher
Replacement of a commercial dishwasher at a hotel.
5/20/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
Retrofit 300 existing High-Pressure Sodium lamps with new LED fixtures in the exterior of the facility.
4/27/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
Replace (12) MH fixtures with LED fixtures.
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
Replace (12) MH fixtures with LED fixtures.
6/23/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures, Lighting - Lamps + Ballasts
LED Fixture, HID Fixture, LED Lamp
Replaced interior highbay and general area lighting with LED fixtures.
6/23/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures, Lighting - Lamps + Ballasts
LED Fixture, LED Lamp, Linear Fluorescent Lamp with Ballast
Replace T5, T8, U6 linear fluorescent with LEDs.
7/1/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
Replaced pole lighting with LEDs.
7/16/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures, Lighting - Lamps + Ballasts
LED Fixture, CFL Fixture, Linear Fluorescent Lamp
Replaced interior general area, linear fluorescent, CLFs, and pole lighting with LEDs.
6/26/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, Linear Fluorescent Fixture, HID Fixture
LED lighting retrofit for existing metal halide and fluorescent fixtures.
7/17/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, Linear Fluorescent Fixture, HID Fixture
LED lighting retrofit for existing metal halide and fluorescent fixtures.
3/2/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology
Centrifugal Water Chiller, Screw Water Chiller, Adjustable Speed Drive
Accelerated replacement of an existing 250 ton water cooled screw process chiller at a bottling plant with a more efficient 160 ton water cooled VFD centrifugal chiller.
4/7/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology
Optimization, Air Economizer, Temperature Reset Control
Implement controls strategy to optimize existing air handling units and chiller operation through temperature resets, set-backs, and economizer operation for cleanroom and office spaces.
4/3/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Pump System
Pipe Insulation
Add insulation on the asphalt hot oil pipes at an asphalt production facility.
4/20/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology
Optimization, Temperature Reset Control
Retro-commissioning of HVAC controls on eleven air handling units supplying 4 buildings at a biotechnology campus.
4/28/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Air Compressor, Food Service
Optimization
Compressed air system controls project at a food processor to bring (1) 200 HP and (2) 125 HP compressors in two separate areas running on their individual pressure bands into a single central arrangement.
5/22/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Air Distribution
Optimization
Implement five (5) RCx BRO measures at a telecom central office facility.
6/29/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology
Optimization, Temperature Reset Control, Adjustable Speed Drive
Implementimg thirteen (13) measures. Eleven (11) are BRO measures and two (2) are add on retrofit (AOE). These measures include IMplement optimum start/stop, optimize economizer controls, duct static pressure reset, data center temperature, VFD controls, hot water plant lockout temperature, reset chilled water supply temperature, condenser water reset.
7/20/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology
Optimization, Temperature Reset Control
Implement eight (8) BRO measures at a large commercial facility.
7/21/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology
Optimization, Temperature Reset Control, Area Whole-building Improvements
Implement eight (8) BRO measures at a large commercial facility.
6/17/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Air Compressor
Optimization
Compressed air system controls project; building up to the Title 24 code in terms of system controls. There are currently (1) 250 horsepower, (1) 200 horsepower, (3) 125 horsepower, (5) 75 horsepower and (1) 50 horsepower compressors in seven separate areas running on their individual pressure bands causing the plant to have more online horsepower than necessary. iZ Systems Automation Platform will be installed to control all eleven compressors based on rate of pressure change algorithms on one central pressure signal in the most efficient arrangement possible.
7/21/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology
Optimization, Air Economizer, Temperature Reset Control
Implement seven(7) BRO measures for a large office. This project involves the following measures: RCM1 – Scheduling Optimization for B2 MAU and B3a AHU-1 through AHU-3 RCM2 – Optimize Economizer Controls on B1 AC-1, B2 AC-1 & AC-2, B3a AHU-2 & AHU-3, and B3b AHU-1 RCM3 – Static Pressure Reset on B1 AC-1 through AC-4, B2 AC-1 & AC-3, and B3a AHU-1 through AHU-3 RCM4 – Supply Air Temperature Reset on B1 AC-1 through AC-4, B2 AC-1 & AC-2, and B3b AHU-1 & AHU-2 RCM5 – Increase Chilled Water Supply Temperature of B2 Chillers Serving Data Center RCM6 – Chilled Water Supply Temperature Reset on B3 Chillers RCM7 – Add Schedule and Lockout Controls on Heating Units (DFs) Fans in B1 and B2
7/17/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Air Compressor
Optimization
EEM-1: Install automation platform to efficiently control air compressors (up to Title-24 compliance). This involves adding the iZ Systems Automation Platform “to control all four compressors based on rate of pressure change algorithms on one central pressure signal in the most efficient arrangement possible.”
11/24/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Air Compressor
Adjustable Speed Drive
The project is Accelerated Replacement (AR) of two (2) 100 HP, single stage, rotary screw air compressors with load/unload control. The proposed replacement is a 200 HP, single stage, rotary screw compressor with VFD control.
7/8/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any, HVAC Technology
All Equipment
Measure 1: INTEGRATED BUILDING-RES-MULTI FAMILY - WHOLE HOUSE Measure 2: HERS Incentive Measure 3: EC Final Incentive
2/5/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
All Equipment
3/10/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
All Equipment
SEM-BRO Year 1
3/10/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
All Equipment
SEM-BRO Year 1
3/10/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
All Equipment
SEM-BRO Year 1
3/16/2021
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Whole Building
Area Whole-building Improvements
NMEC Whole Building
3/16/2021
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Whole Building
Area Whole-building Improvements
NMEC Whole Building
3/16/2021
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
Lighting upgrades for a city. HID pole lighting replaced by LEDs.
3/26/2012
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
All Equipment
This project is not approved because this measure is not incented in NC refrigerated warehouses. For applications of this measure in facilities other than refrigerated warehouses, ED may wish to conduct an industry standard practice assessment in collaboration with PG&E. It appears though that T24 requirement could be considered as the base standard practice even for other industrial sectors. If PG&E would like to discuss ED’s assessment during the weekly call or at a specifically scheduled time, we are available.
8/31/2012
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
All Equipment
The project has been conditionally approved by ED. Refer to ex ante review report (X068 PGE 2K12079864 Phase 2 EAR 2012_0831 ver 2.docx and X068 PGE 2K1209864 ED Calculation 2012_0831.xlxs) for the full requirements and context of this request.
3/19/2012
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
All Equipment
Data request for PGE 2K1277405C.
2/12/2013
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology
All Equipment
ED has found mistakes in the analysis PG&E has submitted. A critical assumption in the PG&E analysis is that the floor-by-floor systems are constant volume reheat. ED had questioned this assumption in their previous review, and was assured that the system was indeed constant volume. But, based on information provided in the retrocommissioning verification report, that assumptions does not seem to be valid. Per revised calculations, ED recommends frozen annual energy savings of 66,769 kWh and 18.23 kW, and gas savings of 5,459 therms
6/13/2012
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Air Compressor
All Equipment
Data request for PGE 2K12085717.
9/10/2012
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Air Compressor, Motor Speed Control (Non-HVAC)
Optimization, All Equipment
Data request for PGE 2K12085717.
7/20/2012
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Air Compressor, HVAC Technology
Optimization
Data request for PGE MBCx001.2.
12/21/2012
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology
Air Economizer, Temperature Reset Control, Adjustable Speed Drive
A conference call with ED consultants, PG&E, and Ecology Action was arranged for December 14, 2012 to discuss the M&V plans proposed by ED for HOTEL001ARCX on November 30, 2012. This project was splintered from the original project submission, HOTEL001RCX, in order to expedite the implementation of other project measures that had been conditionally approved by ED. The M&V plan that was proposed in the phase II HOTEL001ARCX EAR was largely targeted towards collecting baseline information for a hotel guestroom controls measure.
8/31/2015
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology
Air Economizer, Temperature Reset Control, Adjustable Speed Drive
CPUC staff waives further review of the above referenced project. The utility will apply a Gross Realization Rate of 0.9 to the ex ante savings values at project claims.
11/13/2012
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
All Equipment
Energy Division selected PG&E NC0120306 for ED review in July 2012. PG&E provided documentation for this application in August 2012. In response to ED’s follow-up data request, PG&E informed ED that some of the measures originally shown in the application documents had been moved into a third party program and are documented under application number NC0117386. PG&E recently informed ED that the post field inspection for NC0117386 has been completed and final internal review is pending for the project, with incentive payment expected by the end of November 2012.
8/20/2013
Ex Ante Review
Final
PG&E
Any, HVAC Technology
All Equipment
After PG&E recently made changes to this custom project application, PG&E #2K12104029, ED finds the recent submittal acceptable, and therefore, ED chooses to waive further reviews. PG&E will apply the 0.90 GRR factor when filing for this project’s claim.
7/26/2013
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any, HVAC Technology
All Equipment
The majority of the three panel reviewers, by a 2-1 margin, decided that the replacement of HVAC equipment and controls at the is a normal replacement project, not an early replacement project.
3/5/2014
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
Optimization, Heat Recovery
Insulate new steam pipes: Install for new construction 3” mineral wool insulation on 191,000 feet of “open field” oilfield pipelines.
11/15/2013
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Ballasts, Lighting - Lamps
Irrigation System, LED Lamp
CPUC staff custom projects ex ante review team held a conference call on November 15, 2013 with PG&E and the 3P implementer, EMCOR, on the large phase 1 campus lighting project. PG&E is currently having EMCOR address six calculation issues that ED raised:
11/17/2014
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Ballasts, Lighting - Lamps
Irrigation System, LED Lamp
Commission staff reviewed the documentation for this project received on October 28, 2014 from PG&E. Staff was expecting final savings calculations for a group of five buildings that underwent a lighting fixture and controls retrofit under Project #: 2K1221049C which was conditionally approved at 692,956.8 kWh.
8/2/2013
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any, HVAC Technology
Optimization, All Equipment, Water Side Economizer
ED is unable to approve the project’s ex ante savings until the following are clarified: 1. Data center load is 56 W/sf, or about 28% of design value. 2. CRAH supply/return temperature rise is 12 deg F, which is less than half of the expected value. Thus, even if the data center goes up to the original design load, the fan power savings would be significantly reduced compared to the original estimate. 3. In the July trend data, the condenser entering temperature is sometimes lower than the outdoor wet bulb temperature, which is not possible. Some effort should be made to determine the cause of this discrepancy and to formulate a possible workaround to make use of the valid portions of the trend data. 4. The “Actual” chiller performance curve is based on a condenser entering temperature of 72 deg F. The analysis should account for the degradation in chiller efficiency at higher condensing temperatures in order to make the peak kW calculation accurate. 5. Outdoor temperature is not shown for the January trend data. There are points in that data set where the transition between economizer and chiller operation appears to occur. If outdoor temperature were known, the transition point assumption of 55 F used in the model could be verified. 6. Incremental cost calculations appear to be reasonable.
8/28/2015
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
All Equipment
CPUC staff waives further review of the above referenced project. The utility will apply a Gross Realization Rate of 0.9 to the ex ante savings values at project claims. Upon completion of this project, please upload all final project documentations to this project’s directory in the CMPA. Upon submitting the utility claims for this project to the CPUC, please upload to this project’s directory in the CMPA a document indicating this project’s claim ID and the quarter and year in which the project is claimed.
8/28/2015
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology
Adjustable Speed Drive
CPUC staff waives further review of the above referenced project. The utility will apply a Gross Realization Rate of 0.9 to the ex ante savings values at project claims. Upon completion of this project, please upload all final project documentations to this project’s directory in the CMPA. Upon submitting the utility claims for this project to the CPUC, please upload to this project’s directory in the CMPA a document indicating this project’s claim ID and the quarter and year in which the project is claimed.
6/4/2014
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
Heat Recovery
Upon review of PG&E’s revised calculations (with the almond drying air recirculation removed), CPUC staff waives further review of this project. PG&E is to upload in the CMPA project file the project’s final energy savings calculations, the incentive payments, and the completed IR package. Also, PG&E is to include the actual PG&E Claim ID numbers for each measure, once incentives are paid, in its claims reporting.
10/28/2014
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, Linear Fluorescent Fixture, HID Fixture
Commission staff waives further review of the above referenced project. PG&E should apply a GRR of 0.9 to the utility’s post-installation trued up gross savings for this project at claims.
8/28/2015
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
All Equipment
CPUC staff waives further review of the above referenced project. The utility will apply a Gross Realization Rate of 0.9 to the ex ante savings values at project claims. Upon completion of this project, please upload all final project documentations to this project’s directory in the CMPA. Upon submitting the utility claims for this project to the CPUC, please upload to this project’s directory in the CMPA a document indicating this project’s claim ID and the quarter and year in which the project is claimed.
7/8/2015
Ex Ante Review
Final
PG&E
Heat Exchanger
Optimization, All Equipment
Project Descriptions: High Emissivity Coating on Furnace Refractory: The measure proposes to increase the heat transfer efficiency by applying a proprietary water-based coating to refractory surfaces inside an industrial furnace. Final Memo Summary: CPUC Staff note that PG&E staff has satisfactorily responded to the requirements in Staff’s final disposition. The final ex ante savings have been revised to match the CPUC Staff recommended values of 590,078 therms, 0 kW, 0 kWh. The project is an REA project type with project cost of $315,055.
6/9/2015
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology
Temperature Reset Control
Project Descriptions: The customer proposes to implement four RCx measures at a large office building in order to improve the operational efficiency of the HVAC system. EAR Waiver Summary: CPUC staff waives further review of the above referenced project. However, PG&E must address the below issues and upload the requested items with the final project documentation onto this project’s folder in the CMPA: • The project’s measure costs are not itemized. PG&E must obtain and upload the itemized measure costs, including equipment and labor costs by measure, to the project’s CMPA folder. • The CHW Reset eligibility is still a concern since a facility built in 1976 would have replaced their original chillers by now. That history was not documented. If the chillers were replaced when the 2005 Title 24 went into effect, then the CHW Reset measure may not be eligible. PG&E must determine if and when the facility chillers were replaced, obtain and review the permit for the chiller replacement, and determine the measure eligibility. If the CHW Reset is found to be ineligible, CHW Reset must be incorporated into the baseline modeling and the ex ante savings estimates and incentives revised. • PG&E intends to pay an incentive for a zero cost measure, a chiller schedule operational change, because the savings and costs are bundled at the project level, and the incentive cap doesn’t kick in. This appears to circumvent the program rules not to provide incentives to measures with a one year or less simple payback. The incentive for this measure represents $4,276.66, about 5% of the total incentives. PG&E must provide rationale to justify awarding an incentive for this no cost measure and not following the stipulated program rules.
4/6/2021
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology
Adjustable Speed Drive
Project Descriptions: Seven (7) HVAC & Guest room controls measures: HVAC retrofit project for a luxury hotel. Document Summary: The EEM1 (guestroom controls) post M&V plan intends to collect a sample of guestroom FCU operation, guestroom occupancy data, and daily vacancy data (for the sampled guestrooms and the average for the hotel) over a period of two weeks in order to modify the hotel eQUEST model with site-specific findings. Fan motor state and time-series supply & return temperatures will also be collected over a period of 2 weeks. These data will be used to create site-specific heating and cooling hourly thermostat schedules for the guestroom zones in the eQUEST model. The guestroom zones and respective thermostat schedules can be categorized in to rented and unrented room types using the collected vacancy data.
7/26/2013
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
Project Description: This project, involves the removal of fixtures and replacing them with a total of 38 fixtures. Document Summary: ED observations and recommendations.
9/3/2013
Ex Ante Review
Final
PG&E
Steam Circulation
Steam Line
Project Description: Steam valve replacement: Replacing steam let down valve with an automated valve to reduce excess steam vented to atmosphere. Document Summary: By this memo, Staff reaffirms denial of project IRCx 050 completely – as a retrofit or an RCx measure. PG&E should not claim any savings from IRCx 050.
1/16/2016
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Controls, Lighting - Fixtures
Light Sensor, Linear Fluorescent Fixture, HID Fixture
Project Description: Lighting and Controls: Linear fluorescent and HID lighting retrofit with occupancy sensor installation. Document Summary: CPUC Staff waives the post-installation review of this project. PG&E will apply a GRR of 0.9 to the final M&V ex ante savings results of approximately 900,000 kWh at project claims. PG&E will upload all final documentation for this project to the CMPA. PG&E will also upload to the CMPA a document indicating this project's claim ID number and the quarter and year this project was claim when those information are available.
10/23/2013
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology, Lighting - Fixtures
Project Description: HVAC and Lighting retrofits: Several lighting projects spanning multiple locations and one HVAC central plant retrofit project for an institutional office facility. Document Summary: HVAC project 1. Provide a status update for the HVAC portion of the project. Has design been completed? Has equipment been ordered? When is installation expected to begin? 2. ED cannot fully comprehend the scope of the HVAC project. A detailed description of the existing and proposed systems has not been provided. 3. For each affected system, provide a description of the existing and proposed equipment, system type and configuration, numbers of units, capacity, hours of operation, controls, set points, reset and lockout strategies, normal hours of occupancy for areas served by the affected equipment, etc. Provide the age and condition of the affected equipment.... Lighting projects 1. Please provide a facsimile of the original application form signed and dated by the customer representative. Please provide evidence of program influence to support the early retirement claims for the lighting retrofits. 2. Please provide an unlocked version of the modified lighting calculator or the password to unlock the spreadsheet. 3. Provide a site-by-site status update for the lighting portion of the project. Has equipment been ordered? When is installation expected to begin?...
11/3/2013
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology, Lighting - Fixtures
Project Description: HVAC and Lighting retrofits: Several lighting projects spanning multiple locations and one HVAC central plant retrofit project for an institutional office facility. Document Summary: Revised from file X380 Notes 2013-10-23.pdf.
8/11/2015
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Space Heating Equipment
Gas Furnace
Project Description: Rotary Hearth Furnaces: Replacement of Two Furnaces for Increased Production. Document Summary: CPUC staff waives further review of the above referenced project. The utility will apply a Gross Realization Rate of 0.9 to the ex ante savings values at project claims. Upon completion of this project, please upload all final project documentations to this project’s directory in the CMPA. Upon submitting the utility claims for this project to the CPUC, please upload to this project’s directory in the CMPA a document indicating this project’s claim ID and the quarter and year in which the project is claimed.
9/13/2013
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
HVAC Technology
This email contains an initial review of the project X390 KEAI-027 Phase 2 (EEGA 7915), a controls upgrade project involving 1.) HVAC supply air static pressure reset and, 2.) night time sweep controls. This email also contains a request for additional documentation of the pre-existing conditions and proposed project.
12/24/2014
Ex Ante Review
Final
PG&E
Space Heating Equipment
Gas Furnace
Project Description: Tube Seals on Crude Oil Furnaces: Replace degraded tube seals on three (3) crude oil furnaces. Document Summary: By this memo, Staff reaffirms denial of project IRCx 050 completely – as a retrofit or an RCx measure. PG&E should not claim any savings from IRCx 050.
12/12/2013
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any, HVAC Technology
All Equipment
The documents posted did not include final calculations spreadsheet. The application package appeared to use about 8300 hours to calculate savings, not 6900 hours. Since the DOE tool does not seem to have a way to enter local weather data, suggest use hours when the outside temperature is 75 F or less, not the compressor operating hours. Ideally the temperature differential at which dampers open should be similar to an HVAC economizer operation. The suggested 75F temperature is probably liberal.
4/16/2014
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
All Equipment
Project Description: Ring valve upgrade: Replacing plate valves with ring valves. Document Summary: Commission staff (CS) has reviewed PG&E’s partial response dated February 11, 2014 to the CS Show Stopper Review dated January 3, 2014 (Attachment 1 - see pages 2-4 of this document for reference) and accepts PG&E’s explanation that replacing a plate valve with a ring valve is NOT industry standard practice. However, there is a great discrepancy between PG&E’s claim of 20 years as EUL of ring valves as compared to not-to-exceed typical estimate of 3 years found from research CS consultants conducted (item #4 of CS disposition).
1/28/2014
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture, HID Fixture
Project Description: LED fixtures: The project will replace the exterior High Pressure Sodium (HPS) and Metal Halide (MH) fixtures with LED Fixtures. Document Summary: CPUC staff has reviewed the utility's resubmitted initial savings estimate of 493,636 kWh and 120.4 kW (based on the correct PSMH baseline), waives further review of this project, and recommends that the utility applies a GRR of 0.9 to the trued-up savings after post-installation M&V.
12/10/2013
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
All Equipment
CPUC staff finds that this project's measure and the dates are outside the scope and enforcement dates of a recent ISP. Therefore we will waive the ex ante review of this project. This project will receive the GRR of 0.9 applied at utility claims.
1/13/2014
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
All Equipment
Project Description: Sawmill Upgrade: Replace hydraulic drives with electronic drives; upgrade the large log mill that will increase production by 15%, while simultaneously reducing the connected load by 690 HP. Document Summary: During my show-stopper review CPUC staff has two issues that arose during our show-stopper review, which are listed below for this project, X470 - PGE 1206-05 – Large Sawmill Upgrade: 1) PG&E/LMI assigns a normal replacement baseline claim using in situ equipment and conditions. For normal replacement claims, ISP for new construction is the correct baseline. If the IOU & 3rd Party are suggesting that the in situ large saw mill equipment, controls, and configuration would be considered current ISP, then CPUC staff will need this to be clearly demonstrated. A related question that staff would like to understand is whether the 15% capacity expansion is strictly measure-induced or if there is market-driven factors. It is possible that the baseline might be capacity expansion. Nevertheless, whether normal replacement or capacity expansion is the proper baseline is irrelevant because the technical equipment baseline would still remain ISP for new construction, and not the in situ sawmill. A revised baseline analysis appears to be in order. 2) Cogen issue – From previous guidance from CPUC staff, a simple proportional attribution of grid purchases assumes that this measure (which is claimed to save a total of 4.4 million kWh” (2.2 for PG&E’s supply of 2.2 kWh) to “zero-out” the electricity bill for this customer. Previous guidance directs the IOU to demonstrate using at a minimum of daily cogen production (grid exports) and consumption (grid imports) - and perhaps hourly if the data is readily available – needs to demonstrate that the full impact from this project will be seen on the PPP-paying electricity supply.
4/16/2014
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any
All Equipment
Project Description: Ring valve upgrade: Replacing plate valves with ring valves. Document Summary: Commission staff (CS) has reviewed PG&E’s partial response dated February 11, 2014 to the CS Show Stopper Review dated January 3, 2014 (Attachment 1 - see pages 2-4 of this document for reference) and accepts PG&E’s explanation that replacing a plate valve with a ring valve is NOT industry standard practice. However, there is a great discrepancy between PG&E’s claim of 20 years as EUL of ring valves as compared to not-to-exceed typical estimate of 3 years found from research CS consultants conducted (item #4 of CS disposition).
2/10/2014
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Motor Speed Control (Non-HVAC), Pump System
Adjustable Speed Drive, Pump Control
The CPUC custom projects ex-ante review (EAR) team has assessed the application paperwork for PG&E 1570-01 (X485) and has determined that the measure is ineligible for incentives because the equipment has been non-operational in the preceding 12 months. As per the Pre-Installation PCIP Report, the pipeline being served by the pumps has been under line repairs since October 2009 and the pumps have been dormant (refer to Section 3.1.2 Existing Conditions, p. 5). The proposed VFD measure is planned to be installed on pumps that have not operated over the past 12 months. Since the IOU custom programs do not allow EE measures installed on equipment that has been non-operational in the preceding 12-months, staff rejects the proposed project.
6/3/2014
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Pump System
Pump - General Purpose Motor
Project Description: Ag Pumping: Replace agricultural well pump and bowl. Document Summary: Commission Staff request the following information related to project NC0128786 (X495) Job # 6033: 1. What are the type(s) of crops served by this new booster pump? Is this pump serving a new field that has never before been irrigated or was it recently converted from a different crop? Is the booster pump fed from a well or an irrigation ditch? If served by a well, what is the age of the well pump and was it recently renovated or was a new well drilled?...
4/7/2021
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any, Whole Building
All Equipment
Project Description: Whole Building New Construction: Whole building energy evaluation for office building. Document Summary: X500 disposition points for discussion: 1. “Most of the savings for the project are a result of changing from a packaged VAV system in the Standard case to a variable refrigerant flow heat pump system. A detailed review of the input files from the Standard case model revealed that the HVAC systems in this model did not have economizers or supply air temperature reset control, which are both required by the 2008 Title 24 energy code for this type of system.” The ED assumes that economizers and supply air temperature reset controls should be prescriptively required in the baseline mechanical system. The baseline mechanical system in this case is an air-cooled packaged VAV system. AESC addressed why the prescriptive requirement for economizers does not apply in this case. The prescriptive requirement for supply air temperature reset control does not apply in this case because supply air temperature reset is not required in cases where the system has controls that prevent reheating, recooling, and simultaneous heating and cooling to the same zone. The VRF systems here as designed do not have the ability to reheat or re-cool, or simultaneously heat and cool a zone. Thus, the prescriptive requirement for supply air temperature reset does not apply in this case. Explanation:...
5/12/2015
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any, Whole Building
All Equipment
Project Description: Whole Building New Construction: Whole building energy evaluation for office building. Document Summary: CPUC staff reviewed PG&E’s response to staff’s Phase 1 Ex Ante Review (EAR) data request dated February 6, 2015. This project is not approved. CPUC staff found the utility response to be non-responsive. 1. In the Phase 1 EAR data request, CPUC staff indicated that: “There was nothing in the submitted documents to support the lighting power density values used in the proposed building model. The submission needs to include lighting schedules from construction documents as well as spreadsheets developed to calculate the proposed lighting power densities.” PG&E’s response was, ”Please refer to the LTG design drawings (plans and schedules), Title 24 documents and the design team’s energy efficiency report”. However, these documents were not included in any of files submitted to CPUC for this project.
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any, Whole Building
All Equipment
Project Description: Whole Building New Construction: Whole building energy evaluation for office building. Document Summary: ED Summary of Review Issues: Most of the savings for the project are a result of changing from a packaged VAV system in the Standard case to a variable refrigerant flow heat pump system. A detailed review of the input files from the Standard case model revealed that the HVAC systems in this model did not have economizers or supply air temperature reset control, which are both required by the 2008 Title 24 energy code for this type of system. PG&E Response: Section 144 (3) 1 of The Energy Efficiency Standards is a Prescriptive Criteria, not a Mandatory Measure. Economizers are not “required” by code here.
4/7/2021
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Any, Motor Speed Control (Non-HVAC)
All Equipment, Adjustable Speed Drive
Project Description: New Pipeline: New oil pipeline diameter increased from baseline 12" to 16." Document Summary: While the requested revisions associated with the Phase I EAR have been provided, we believe significant additional information is needed as a result of the recently completed ISP study on the use of a VFD for the pumping system. While a decision was initially made to separate the increase in the pipe diameter as a measure from the VFD as a measure so as to not delay either, it is now clear to commission staff that the two should be considered together....
9/4/2014
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
PG&E
Lighting - Fixtures
LED Fixture
Commission staff has performed a show-stopper review and finds that EEM 3 (Photocells and Timers) and EEM 4b (occupancy sensors) are at-code measures proposed as retrofit add-ons. The CPUC policy does not allow installation of at-code measures as explained during the ED-IOU technical collaboration call on September 2, 2014. Staff will be willing to waive this project from further review subject to the removal EEM 3 and EEM 4b. In that case, PG&E should apply a GRR of 0.9 to the post-installation trued up savings estimate of the remaining measures. Please confirm acceptance, or not acceptance, of this proposed disposition.
9/10/2019
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Pump System
Pump - General Purpose Motor
9/12/2019
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Whole Building
Whole Building Retrofit Package
9/11/2019
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
HVAC Air Distribution
HVAC Supply Fan - General Purpose Motor
8/29/2019
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Pump System
Pump - General Purpose Motor
8/29/2019
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Motor Speed Control (Non-HVAC)
Pump - General Purpose Motor
8/29/2019
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Motor Speed Control (Non-HVAC)
Pump - General Purpose Motor
8/29/2019
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Motor Speed Control (Non-HVAC)
Pump - General Purpose Motor
9/30/2019
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Motor Speed Control (Non-HVAC)
Pump - General Purpose Motor
9/30/2019
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Pump System
Pump - General Purpose Motor
10/22/2019
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Whole Building
Site Whole-Building Improvements
11/15/2019
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Whole Building
Site Whole-Building Improvements
10/15/2019
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
HVAC Air Distribution, HVAC Technology
Air Economizer, HVAC Supply Fan - General Purpose Motor, Flow Plus Temperature Controls
10/15/2019
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
HVAC Air Distribution, HVAC Technology
Air Economizer, HVAC Supply Fan - General Purpose Motor, Thermostat
10/29/2019
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Air Compressor, HVAC Technology
HVAC Exhaust Fan - General Purpose Motor, Pump Control
10/29/2019
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Liquid Circulation, Motor Speed Control (Non-HVAC)
Blower, Flow Control
10/30/2019
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Pump System
Pump - General Purpose Motor
11/18/2019
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Pump System
Pump - General Purpose Motor
11/19/2019
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Heat Rejection Equipment
Optimization
11/26/2019
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Pump System
Pump - General Purpose Motor
11/25/2019
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Heat Rejection Equipment
Optimization
11/25/2019
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Heat Rejection Equipment
Optimization
2/6/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Lighting - Fixtures
HID Fixture
12/10/2019
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Pump System
Pump - General Purpose Motor
12/10/2019
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Pump System
Pump - General Purpose Motor
12/10/2019
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Pump System
Pump - General Purpose Motor
12/10/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
SCE
Pump System
Pump - General Purpose Motor
1/6/2019
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
HVAC Air Distribution, HVAC Technology
HVAC Ventilation Fan - General Purpose Motor, HVAC Supply Fan - General Purpose Motor, EMS
3/10/2019
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
SCE
Whole Building
Whole Building Retrofit Package
12/8/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Whole Building
Whole Building Retrofit Package
2/20/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Pump System
Pump - General Purpose Motor
2/25/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Whole Building
Site Whole-Building Improvements
2/20/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 2
SCE
Pump System
Pump - General Purpose Motor
3/10/2021
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Pump System
Pump Control
1/30/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
HVAC Air Distribution, Motor
Flow Control, Adjustable Speed Drive
1/30/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Air Compressor
Optimization
1/30/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Motor Speed Control (Non-HVAC)
Flow Control
4/7/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Whole Building
Whole Building Retrofit Package
8/11/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Whole Building
Site Whole-Building Improvements
3/30/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Whole Building
Site Whole-Building Improvements
4/21/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Heat Rejection Equipment
Optimization, Pipe Insulation
2/5/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
SCE
Whole Building
Whole Building Retrofit Package
2/5/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Whole Building
Whole Building Retrofit Package
2/5/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Whole Building
Whole Building Retrofit Package
2/5/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Whole Building
Whole Building Retrofit Package
2/5/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Whole Building
Whole Building Retrofit Package
3/17/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
SCE
dX AC Equipment, HVAC Technology
Flow Control, Air Economizer, Flow Plus Temperature Controls
2/14/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Lighting - Lamps
LED Lamp
6/11/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Whole Building
Whole Building Retrofit Package
4/13/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Pump System
Flow Control
4/14/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Whole Building
Whole Building Retrofit Package
4/24/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 1
SCE
Whole Building
Whole Building Retrofit Package
9/27/2020
Ex Ante Review
Phase 2
SCE
Whole Building
Whole Building Retrofit Package
3/9/2021
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Whole Building
Whole Building Retrofit Package
6/15/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Motor Speed Control (Non-HVAC)
Adjustable Speed Drive
6/2/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Whole Building
Whole Building Retrofit Package
6/2/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Whole Building
Whole Building Retrofit Package
5/12/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Pump System
Pump - General Purpose Motor
6/2/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Whole Building
Whole Building Retrofit Package
5/26/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Whole Building
Whole Building Retrofit Package
5/26/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Whole Building
Whole Building Retrofit Package
8/5/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Whole Building
Whole Building Retrofit Package
8/5/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Whole Building
Whole Building Retrofit Package
5/26/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Whole Building
Whole Building Retrofit Package
5/26/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Whole Building
Whole Building Retrofit Package
6/2/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Pump System
Pump - General Purpose Motor
6/2/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
HVAC Air Distribution, HVAC Technology
Commercial Evaporative Cooler, HVAC Supply Fan - General Purpose Motor, Pump - General Purpose Motor
6/9/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Whole Building
Whole Building Retrofit Package
6/9/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Whole Building
Whole Building Retrofit Package
6/19/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Water Heating Equipment
Site Whole-Building Improvements
9/4/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Whole Building
Site Whole-Building Improvements
9/4/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Whole Building
Whole Building Retrofit Package
9/17/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Pump System
Pump - General Purpose Motor
2/18/2021
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Whole Building
Whole Building Retrofit Package
10/6/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Whole Building
Whole Building Retrofit Package
11/12/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Whole Building
Whole Building Retrofit Package
11/12/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Whole Building
Whole Building Retrofit Package
11/17/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Whole Building
Whole Building Retrofit Package
11/25/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Lighting - Lamps
LED Lamp
10/21/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Any
Pipe Insulation
12/14/2020
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Lighting - Lamps
LED Lamp
2/23/2021
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Whole Building
Whole Building Retrofit Package
3/31/2021
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Whole Building
Whole Building Retrofit Package
3/16/2021
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Whole Building
Whole Building Retrofit Package
1/25/2021
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Whole Building
Whole Building Retrofit Package
4/7/2021
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Whole Building
Whole Building Retrofit Package
4/16/2021
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Motor Speed Control (Non-HVAC)
Blower
4/16/2021
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Motor Speed Control (Non-HVAC)
Blower
3/9/2021
Ex Ante Review
Final
SCE
Any
Agitation/mixing drive